A question (no this does not make much sense)

If I break a 10 dollar blue plush monkey, I should replace/repay the monkey at its value (at 10) and maybe a nice note. Correct?

To clarify I am not required to pay 100+ dollars for a much bigger, fluffier, collectible golden monkey as refund.

This is logic.

"How is a raven like a writing desk?" - the Hatter, Alice in wonderland: through the looking glass.